ZaikaFind

Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine

4.5 (477 reviews)

Indian, Indian • $$

1178 NJ-35

Middletown Township, NJ 07748

+1 732-671-8900

Dine-in

Location

1178 NJ-35, Middletown Township, NJ 07748, United States

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 12 to 2:30 PM, 4 to 9 PM
Wednesday 12 to 2:30 PM, 4 to 9 PM
Thursday 12 to 2:30 PM, 4 to 9 PM
Friday 12 to 2:30 PM, 4 to 9 PM
Saturday 12 to 2:30 PM, 4 to 9 PM
Sunday 12 to 2:30 PM, 4 to 9 PM

Photos

Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine - Restaurant photo
Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine - Restaurant photo
Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine - Restaurant photo
Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine - Restaurant photo
Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine - Restaurant photo

Reviews

Clare N. 2025-01-24

We ordered garlic naan, chicken Tikka masala, and Matar Panir dishes. Then we also ordered the special for 2 that came with Mulligatawny soup, chicken tikka, Lamb Roganjosh, navrattan korma, seekh kebab, basmati rice, and regular naan. Plenty of food for 3 adults and 1 kid; we took home leftovers. Spice level can be customized (mild, medium or spicy). Only mild complaint is the restaurant is realy dark.

Steven 2025-04-26

Been here a few times and have had an amazing experience each time. The butter chicken is to die for and the service is great. Highly recommend

Mike B 2024-11-27

I LOVE THIS PLACE: As a lover of Indian cuisine I have tried several of the local Indian options and Neelam is my most frequented. They have variety and they do it all well. The portions for the price are more than generous and their combo deals are fantastic for take out. Other places nearby make great food as well, but none give you what Neelam does, and they make no sacrifice in quality. The only inconsistency I find is the spice level. I always ask for spicy and some days it's perfect, other times I feel they held back. If you enjoy Indian food, or are curious to try it, Neelam is the place

Dr. Amy Winters 2023-11-10

How is this place not packed 24/7?!?!? The food was amazing and the entire atmosphere was calm and inviting! I ordered a chai to drink and the waitress suggested the Channe Ki Chaat as an appetizer. I did not regret it! I also ordered the garlic nann and shrimp Tikka marsala for dinner with medium spice. It was perfect. It had just the right amount of heat to make you pause before the next bite but also kept the flavor. The prices are reasonable but I felt like it was a steal with how good it was.

Joshi naga venkata akhilesh yadav Gooty 2025-01-04

I’m thrilled to have discovered Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine! The special buffet was absolutely fantastic—packed with a variety of flavorful dishes at an unbeatable price. I couldn’t get enough of the special buffet, and everything was cooked exactly to my liking. The experience was top-notch, and I’ll definitely return for that incredible special buffet again soon!

Ethan Rublowitz 2025-04-26

Butter chicken was so good! i’ve been hear many times and it is so delicious the service is amazing i would throw my kid off a bridge for some of the butter chicken

Barry Evan Blank 2022-12-14

I am so happy I found Neelam Exotic Indian Cuisine. The house special combination was enough for 2 people. Reasonably priced! Everything was perfectly prepared to my request. I enjoyed my meal and will be back!!!